Toolbox · Agrarian notes · 田野之问

Seeing from the field.

SEESALT began in rural classrooms and on farms, and most of what it does still happens in places where a living is made from land. This page keeps what agrarian studies is teaching us, one week at a time, the way our Kiswahili notes keep a language.

Our founder takes part in the graduate seminar and the weekly colloquium of Yale’s Program in Agrarian Studies as a student. SEESALT has no affiliation with the Program. Colloquium papers are drafts shared in advance with participants; nothing from them is summarised or quoted here. What is recorded is our own questions.

Three premises, and how we try to keep them

The Program states three premises. Each one is a test we can fail.

The Program sets out three premises on its own page, paraphrased below. Under each is what keeping it would mean for an organisation like ours, and where we try.

1

Begin with lived experience

Any account of agrarian change starts from how the people living it understand and value their own situation.

For us this is the difference between knowing and saying. In Guhuza, young people knew the facts about HIV; what stood in the way was the room. Sunward starts from what rural teenagers are proud of, not from what a survey says they lack.

2

Never wall off the South

The study of the Global South should not be separated from the history of the West, nor the humanities from the social sciences.

Our founder’s first published farm study is in Osceola, Wisconsin, not in a village abroad: a community-supported farm in the American Midwest, read with the same food-security questions we bring to rural Hunan. And our mark carries two trees on one ground, with no arrow between them.

3

Trespass, creatively

Disciplines loosen their hold when they work together on themes that matter to all of them.

SEESALT puts anthropologists, economists and climate technologists at the same table on purpose. Adaptation Lab exists because a measurement problem in climate finance turned out to be an ethnographic one.

What we took from James C. Scott

Three ideas from the scholar who built the Program, and where they live in our work.

James C. Scott founded the Program in Agrarian Studies and led it for decades; he died in 2024. The Program keeps a page remembering him. Three of his ideas run quietly through SEESALT, usually under other names.

LegibilitySeeing Like a State, 1998States simplify what they govern so that it can be counted, and the simplification then remakes the thing counted. Adaptation Lab’s question about eligibility indicators is a legibility question.
MētisSeeing Like a State, 1998Practical knowledge that lives in experience and resists being written down. Close to what the economist Don Lavoie called tacit knowledge, and the thing a facilitator in a Rwandan classroom has and a manual does not.
Everyday resistanceWeapons of the Weak, 1985Foot-dragging, feigned ignorance, small evasions: politics carried on by people who cannot afford open defiance. Read before reading any compliance rate as consent.

The thread so far · Fall 2026

Each week leaves us one question. Read in order, they make an argument.

We began by asking what a peasant is, moved to who gets seen and counted as one, and arrived at who draws the lines. These are the questions we kept, one per week; each links to the notes it came from.

  1. 18 SeptWhat travelsWhat travels best is the version made for strangers. Does protecting it ever protect the practice that needs the forest?
  2. 25 SeptThe invisible stateWhen a state is everywhere in the record and nowhere in experience, is that invisibility part of what makes time feel stopped?
  3. 30 SeptSeminar · peasants without a ploughDoes “peasant” need agriculture at all?
  4. 2 OctBeing countedWhat does it cost to stay uncounted, who can afford to stay invisible, and who keeps the ledger once the count is done?
  5. 9 OctWho is localWhen the most local government draws the line, what keeps “community-led” from meaning “led by whoever was here first”?
  6. 30 OctDisaster as a recordHow much of what gets called a natural disaster is a record of who could afford the cure, and who was left to remember it as something done to them?
  7. 6 NovA house the state gaveWhen people accuse the state of betrayal while living in what it gave them, what was the promise, and who was never offered it?
  8. 13 NovStill open.

The colloquium, as a reading list · Fall 2026

Countryside and city: what links them, and what each makes of the other.

This year’s theme asks how countryside and city see each other, and what moves between them: extraction, migration, credit, law and political order. Below is the public schedule, with one question of ours beside each session. The schedule is the Program’s; the questions are ours. Where a session or that week’s graduate seminar left us with something, our notes are folded beneath the row. Each week also carries one reading from Africa, marked as such, because that is where much of our own work, and our founder’s research, is done.

  • 18 SeptLand, Learning, and Resistance: Yanomami Knowledge and Environmental JusticeEmil’ Keme, Emory UniversityOur questionWhat, if anything, of this knowledge can travel beyond the forest? Rights travel easily because they are abstract; the knowledge they are meant to protect does not.
    Colloquium · 18 SeptWhat travels, and what staysOur notes

    The session took up a chapter in progress, shared with participants in advance, so nothing from it is summarised here. What is kept is our own: the question we asked, and where it led when we went back to published work on Indigenous knowledge and how it moves. Nothing said in the room by others is reported.

    A book made to cross a border

    Davi Kopenawa told his life and thought to the anthropologist Bruce Albert in Yanomami, and addressed the result to outsiders: The Falling Sky (2010 in French; English 2013). Some of this knowledge travels because its holder chose to send it, in a form built for readers he would never meet.

    For us.When knowledge reaches us, we ask who chose to send it, in what form and for whom, before we file it as data.

    A database is not a forest

    Arun Agrawal argued that the line between “indigenous” and “scientific” knowledge does not hold up, and that projects which gather local knowledge into archives cut it off from the people and practices that keep it alive (Development and Change, 1995).

    For us.A register of what farmers know records past answers. It cannot answer the next question. We do not call a knowledge database preservation.

    Universals move by friction

    Anna Tsing showed that global ideas such as rights or conservation move only when they catch on particular places and people, and that they change as they do (Friction, 2005). Rights look portable because the work of carrying them is spread across many hands.

    For us.A right reaches a village through a particular person. We find out who that person is.

    Who speaks for the forest

    Beth Conklin and Laura Graham traced how Amazonian leaders and environmentalists allied around the image of Indigenous people as natural conservationists (American Anthropologist, 1995). The image gave leverage, and it was fragile: support could fall away when a community did something the image did not allow.

    For us.When we tell a community’s story to funders, we notice which version travels best, and what that version commits the community to.

    Land as a school

    Leanne Betasamosake Simpson writes of land as pedagogy: knowledge learned by being on the land and in relation, which cannot be moved whole into a classroom (As We Have Always Done, 2017). If that is right, moving people off land also closes a school.

    For us.When a programme resettles people, as Rwanda’s villagisation (imidugudu) did from the late 1990s, we count what can no longer be learned where people now live, not only the houses built.

    A boundary on paper

    Brazil ratified the Yanomami Indigenous Territory in 1992, some 9.6 million hectares. Illegal gold mining went on inside it, and in January 2023 the federal government declared a public health emergency there. A recognised boundary was where the struggle over enforcement began, not where it ended.

    For us.When a right is won on paper, we ask who will enforce it at the edge, and what doing so costs them.

    African counterpoint

    Becoming Indigenous

    Dorothy Hodgson followed Maasai activists in Tanzania who took up the global language of Indigenous rights in the 1990s. It won them a hearing at the UN, and then fitted pastoralist politics at home only in part (Being Maasai, Becoming Indigenous, 2011). Here the framework itself travelled, from the Americas to East Africa.

    For us.When a framework arrives from elsewhere, we ask what it lets people say, and what it makes harder to say.

    The question we are keeping. We asked what of this knowledge can travel. Our tentative answer: what travels best is the version made for strangers (a book, a right, an image), and what stays is the practice that needs the forest. Does protecting the first ever protect the second?

    Read with: Davi Kopenawa and Bruce Albert, The Falling Sky (2010; English 2013); Arun Agrawal, “Dismantling the Divide between Indigenous and Scientific Knowledge”, Development and Change (1995); Beth A. Conklin and Laura R. Graham, “The Shifting Middle Ground”, American Anthropologist (1995); Anna Lowenhaupt Tsing, Friction (2005); Leanne Betasamosake Simpson, As We Have Always Done (2017); Dorothy L. Hodgson, Being Maasai, Becoming Indigenous (2011); James C. Scott, Seeing Like a State (1998).

  • 25 SeptAgrarian Questions: The Latin American Novel on the Road to CapitalismEricka Beckman, University of PennsylvaniaOur questionThe Mexican state is everywhere in the history of the ejido and nowhere in Rulfo’s frozen present. Is that invisibility part of what traps his peasants?
    Colloquium · 25 SeptThe state in the flashbackOur notes

    The session took up Ericka Beckman’s Agrarian Questions (Verso, 2026). What is kept here is our own: the question we asked, and where it led when we went back to the novels themselves. Nothing said in the room by others is reported.

    The state appears once

    In Juan Rulfo’s “Nos han dado la tierra” (1953), a few men walk across a dry plain toward the land that reform has granted them. The state appears only in a remembered scene. An official tells them the land is theirs though it has no water, that their enemy is “the large estates … not the Government,” and that any complaint must be made in writing. The men cannot write. Akhil Gupta reads writing itself as the medium through which bureaucracy excludes the poor (Red Tape, 2012).

    For us.Every form we ask a family to fill in is a small version of that scene. We ask who in the household can write, and who has to ask someone else.

    Everywhere in the record, nowhere in the story

    The Mexican state never left the ejido. It created it, extended credit and price supports to it, and from 1938 organised ejidatarios into the ruling party through the National Peasant Confederation. Yet Rulfo’s stories hold no roads, no cars, no offices, though Rulfo himself travelled the countryside by highway in the 1950s, selling tyres and writing for a road guide.

    For us.When people tell us the government never comes, we ask what of the state is already there and simply not seen as the state.

    Naming is governing

    Ejidatario, comunero, inquilino read like local vocabulary, but many such words were written by land and labour law. Scott’s legibility runs in both directions: the state names people so that it can count them, and people then live inside the name and bargain with it.

    For us.The categories in our indicators will become words people use about themselves. We choose them as if they will stick.

    A cushion that becomes a graveyard

    The rural sociologist Ernest Feder warned that the small plot could turn from a “safety cushion” into the smallholder’s graveyard (Social Scientist, 1979). Roger Bartra called the Mexican pattern permanent primitive accumulation: reform tied households to plots too poor to live on, the cities could not absorb them, and people moved back and forth without arriving anywhere.

    For us.Support that keeps a household afloat can also keep it in place. We ask what a programme makes possible next, not only what it prevents.

    Who brings the electricity

    In José Donoso’s El lugar sin límites (1966), set during Chilean land reform, a dying town waits for electricity, and it is the landowner who promises to bring it. Infrastructure arrives, if it arrives, through a private patron rather than the state.

    For us.Where a state is thin, someone else gets the credit for the road or the clinic. We note whose name goes on the service, because that is whom people learn to petition.

    African counterpoint

    The state in the shape of a chief

    Mahmood Mamdani argued that colonial rule in Africa governed the countryside through “customary” chiefs, so that rural people met the state mostly as a chief. He called the arrangement decentralised despotism, and traced how it outlived independence (Citizen and Subject, 1996).

    For us.When people say the government never comes, we ask whether it comes as the chief.

    The question we are keeping. In Rulfo’s Mexico the state was present in law, credit and party, and absent from the stories people told about their lives. When a state is everywhere in the record and nowhere in experience, is that invisibility part of what makes time feel stopped?

    Read with: Juan Rulfo, El Llano en llamas (1953); José Donoso, El lugar sin límites (1966); Ernest Feder, “Regeneration and Degeneration of the Peasants”, Social Scientist (1979); Roger Bartra, Agrarian Structure and Political Power in Mexico (1993); James C. Scott, Seeing Like a State (1998); Mahmood Mamdani, Citizen and Subject (1996); Akhil Gupta, Red Tape (2012); Ericka Beckman, Agrarian Questions (2026).

  • 2 OctSeeing Like the State or Measuring Like a Peasant: A RevisitFrancisco Gutiérrez Sanín, Universidad Nacional de ColombiaOur questionScott taught us to ask what being seen costs. What does it cost not to be counted, and who decides which of the two a community can afford?
    Seminar · 30 SeptBlack peasantries, and freedom that had to be boughtOur notes

    The seminar read Claudia Leal, Landscapes of Freedom: Building a Postemancipation Society in the Rainforest of Western Colombia (2018), on the free Black communities of Colombia’s Pacific lowlands between 1850 and 1930. As with the colloquium, what is kept here is our own: what we noticed, and what it changes for SEESALT. Nothing said in the room by others is reported.

    Simultaneously

    Sidney Mintz wrote that the making of Caribbean peasantries was “simultaneously an act of Westernization and an act of resistance” (Caribbean Transformations, 1974). The weight sits on the first word. People who left the plantation to farm for themselves did it with the tools of the order they were leaving: private plots, markets, the church. The ambiguity is not a stage on the way to something cleaner.

    For us.A family that joins a programme to get out from under one constraint also takes on the programme’s terms. Neither half is the whole story.

    The largest flow is not the familiar one

    On the standard map of the Atlantic slave trade, the widest arrow crosses the South Atlantic from West Central Africa to Brazil and never touches Europe; mainland North America gets a thin line. Spanish America looks small too, partly because many captives reached it second-hand through Caribbean ports (Borucki, Eltis and Wheat, American Historical Review, 2015). The first and last known transatlantic slaving voyages both landed in Spanish colonies.

    For us.Before generalising, we ask which case our intuitions were built on.

    Freedom that was paid for

    In the gold-mining lowlands, enslaved people worked their free days for themselves and bought their freedom; Leal calls it freedom “paid for rather than granted” (p. 51). Across the Atlantic world, freedom was nearly always paid for by someone. The British state compensated slaveholders in the 1830s. Spanish American free-womb laws made the children of enslaved mothers serve their mothers’ owners until eighteen or later. In the lowlands, the enslaved paid in their own gold. Almost no one paid the freed.

    For us.When a programme asks people to co-invest in their own way out, we ask who else is being paid, and who is not.

    Laziness is a labour complaint

    Leal borrows Michael Taussig’s “moral topography” for the way Colombian elites mapped Blackness onto a hellish jungle, and missions set out to cure lowlanders of laziness. The charge recurs wherever freed people had land to fall back on and declined to work for others; Thomas Carlyle made it about Jamaica in 1849.

    For us.Before reading low turnout as apathy, we ask what people can fall back on. It is Scott’s lesson seen from the other side: refusal can be made to look like idleness.

    Autonomy at the edge of the state

    The lowlanders’ autonomy rested partly on the state not reaching them. A state that lived on concessions to outside capital and on taxing exports had little reason to bargain with the people who mined and gathered. Freedom and state absence were produced together.

    For us.Making a place legible to a programme can end the autonomy its illegibility protected. Adaptation Lab’s indicators have to be read with that cost in view.

    One church, two theologies

    In the early twentieth century Colombia handed the schooling of its frontier mission territories, the Chocó among them, to Catholic missions. In the 1980s, church pastoral teams in the same Chocó, shaped by liberation theology, helped Black river communities organise; that road led to Law 70 of 1993 and collective land titles. Both times the church stood in for a thin state. What changed was the direction, and the change was one of time more than of place.

    For us.SEESALT often works where the state is thin. That position is never neutral, and it can point either way.

    African counterpoint

    From slaves to squatters

    Frederick Cooper followed former slaves on Zanzibar and the Kenyan coast after abolition. Many took up land as squatters and worked for themselves when they could; planters and colonial officials called this idleness and used vagrancy and labour rules to push them back to plantation work (From Slaves to Squatters, 1980).

    For us.The same lesson from across another ocean: a charge of laziness usually marks the place where people had an alternative.

    The question we are keeping. Mintz tied peasantry to cultivation, and Eric Wolf’s classic definition begins with “rural cultivators” too. Leal’s lowlanders panned gold, fished, gathered tagua and farmed. Keep the rest of Wolf’s definition, a household working for itself while yielding a surplus to others, drop the word “cultivators”, and they are peasants without a plough. Does “peasant” need agriculture at all?

    Read with: Sidney W. Mintz, Caribbean Transformations (1974); Claudia Leal, Landscapes of Freedom (2018); Alex Borucki, David Eltis and David Wheat, “Atlantic History and the Slave Trade to Spanish America”, American Historical Review (2015); Eric R. Wolf, Peasants (1966); Frederick Cooper, From Slaves to Squatters (1980).

    Colloquium · 2 OctAsking to be countedOur notes

    The session took up an article in progress, shared with participants in advance, so nothing from it is summarised here. What is kept is our own: the question we asked, and where it led when we went back to published work on measurement, statistics and land records. Nothing said in the room by others is reported.

    One measure for the realm

    Witold Kula showed that in old-regime Europe the size of a bushel was something lords and peasants fought over, because a lord’s measure could be a way of taking more (Measures and Men, 1986). In 1789 many village cahiers de doléances asked for a single system of weights and measures across the kingdom. Uniform measurement was, among other things, a peasant demand.

    For us.A common yardstick can protect the weaker side of a bargain. Before we resist a standard, we ask who gains from the confusion.

    A category with rights attached

    In 2018 a Colombian Supreme Court tutela ruling (STP2028-2018) ordered the state to define and count the campesinado. In July 2023 Congress amended Article 64 of the Constitution to recognise the campesinado as a subject of rights and of special protection. At the UN, the Declaration on the Rights of Peasants was adopted in 2018.

    For us.Once a category carries rights, people will argue their way into it. Our indicators work as eligibility rules whether we mean them to or not.

    African counterpoint

    Poor numbers

    Morten Jerven showed how thin the data under many African national accounts are. When Ghana rebased its GDP in 2010, measured output rose by about 60 percent overnight (Poor Numbers, 2013). The economy was the same; the counting changed.

    For us.We publish how each number was made, so that a reader can tell a finding from an artefact of method.

    The theory inside an indicator

    Sally Engle Merry found that indicators carry the theory of whoever designed them, and that a measure that is easy to collect tends to push out one that means more (The Seductions of Quantification, 2016).

    For us.Adaptation Lab writes down what each indicator assumes before anyone uses it.

    A register has to be kept

    Rwanda’s Land Tenure Regularisation demarcated more than ten million parcels by 2013, at well under ten dollars a parcel. Keeping the record current proved harder: in 2013–14 the registry recorded only about ten thousand transactions, and World Bank researchers set out to learn why later sales and inheritances stayed informal (Ali, Deininger and Duponchel, 2016).

    For us.Being counted once is not the same as staying counted. We ask who will update a record, and what it costs a household to keep it true.

    More than one authority keeps lists

    Ana Arjona shows armed groups in Colombia governing civilians where they hold territory, setting rules and settling disputes (Rebelocracy, 2016). Where authority is shared like this, a list of names is something more than one ruler wants.

    For us.We collect the least we need, and decide before fieldwork who must never see it.

    The question we are keeping. Scott taught us to ask what being seen costs. The reverse question is as hard: what does it cost to stay uncounted, who can afford to stay invisible, and who keeps the ledger once the count is done?

    Read with: Witold Kula, Measures and Men (1986); James C. Scott, Seeing Like a State (1998); Corte Suprema de Justicia, STP2028-2018; Acto Legislativo 01 de 2023 (Colombia); UN Declaration on the Rights of Peasants and Other People Working in Rural Areas (2018); Morten Jerven, Poor Numbers (2013); Sally Engle Merry, The Seductions of Quantification (2016); Daniel Ayalew Ali, Klaus Deininger and Marguerite Duponchel, Sustaining the Success of the Systematic Land Tenure Registration in Rwanda (World Bank, 2016); Ana Arjona, Rebelocracy (2016).

  • 9 OctRacializing Water and Agrarian Belonging in a Changing ClimateMargiana Petersen-Rockney, University of MontanaOur questionOur premises lean on the local: decisions made close to the people they touch. Who counts as local, and what protects a newcomer from the neighbours?
    Colloquium · 9 OctWhen local is not safeOur notes

    The session took up an article in progress, shared with participants in advance, so nothing from it is summarised here. What is kept is our own: the question we asked, and where it led when we went back to published work and the public record on water in the American West. Nothing said in the room by others is reported.

    First in time

    Western American water law mostly follows prior appropriation: in a shortage, the oldest right is served first. Donald Worster traced how federal reclamation built the irrigated West around that rule (Rivers of Empire, 1985). In the Klamath Basin, Oregon’s 2013 adjudication ranked the Klamath Tribes’ claims as dating from “time immemorial”, ahead of every irrigator.

    For us.In a shortage, the rule that ranks claims decides who goes dry before anyone argues about causes. We find that rule first.

    Two dry years, two outcomes

    In the 2001 drought the Bureau of Reclamation cut irrigation deliveries in the Klamath Project to protect listed fish, and farmers protested in large numbers. In 2002 deliveries were restored, and at least 33,000 adult salmon died in the lower river, by some estimates far more. The fish kill set off a tribal-led campaign that ended with four dams removed in 2024.

    For us.A drought has winners and losers before it has a cause. We ask who carried the shortage in each year, and who decided.

    The truck is the water right

    Jesse Ribot and Nancy Peluso separate rights from access, the actual ability to benefit, which runs through technology, capital, markets, labour, authority and identity (Rural Sociology, 2003). In 2021 Siskiyou County, California restricted the trucking of water on roads around a largely Hmong subdivision. A federal judge blocked the ordinances that September, and the county repealed them in 2023 after a settlement.

    For us.We map how water actually reaches a household (well, pipe, truck or neighbour) before we discuss who owns it.

    Emergency as a way of deciding

    Janet Roitman argues that naming a crisis lets some questions be asked and quietly takes others off the table (Anti-Crisis, 2014). Emergency measures skip the ordinary steps of notice and review, which is their purpose and their danger.

    For us.When we or a partner declare an emergency, we write down which decisions have left ordinary review, and when they come back.

    Every commons has a boundary

    Elinor Ostrom showed communities governing shared resources well without state or market, and her first design principle is a clear boundary around who may use them (Governing the Commons, 1990). A boundary is how local governance works, and also how it excludes.

    For us.“Community-led” does not mean fair to the newest arrivals. We ask how long someone must live in a place before they count.

    African counterpoint

    Born from the soil

    Peter Geschiere traced the politics of autochthony in Cameroon and elsewhere: claims to belong because one’s people were there first, which grew sharper as democratisation and decentralisation put land and votes at stake locally (The Perils of Belonging, 2009). Who counts as a stranger can change within one lifetime.

    For us.When “local” decides who gets a resource, we ask who is drawing the line between local and stranger, and when it was last moved.

    The question we are keeping. Every premise on this page favours the local: begin with lived experience, trust what people know. When the most local government is the one drawing the line, what keeps “community-led” from meaning “led by whoever was here first”?

    Read with: Donald Worster, Rivers of Empire (1985); Elinor Ostrom, Governing the Commons (1990); Jesse C. Ribot and Nancy Lee Peluso, “A Theory of Access”, Rural Sociology (2003); Peter Geschiere, The Perils of Belonging (2009); Janet Roitman, Anti-Crisis (2014); Oregon Water Resources Department, Klamath Basin Adjudication (2013); Lo v. County of Siskiyou, E.D. Cal. (2021).

  • 16 OctOf Carbon and Displacement: India’s Compensatory ForestsChitrangada Choudhury, University of ZurichNote to follow.Read alongside, from Africa: James Fairhead, Melissa Leach and Ian Scoones, “Green Grabbing”, Journal of Peasant Studies (2012).
  • 30 OctTobacco’s Enemy Number One: Palestinian Fellahin Managing Blue Mold Under Military GovernmentBasma Fahoum, Ben-Gurion University of the NegevOur questionA blight is blind to borders; the institutions it lands on are not. When the same disease reaches several countries in one season, what decides where the crop comes back and where it is gone for good?
    Colloquium · 30 OctA blight that crosses bordersOur notes

    The session took up a chapter in progress, shared with participants in advance, so nothing from it is summarised here. What is kept is our own: the question we asked, and where it led when we went back to published work on plant disease, peasant households and memory. Nothing said in the room by others is reported.

    The pathogen does not stop at the line

    Tobacco blue mold, caused by Peronospora tabacina, is carried on the wind. After it reached Europe in the late 1950s it moved across the continent and into the eastern Mediterranean within a few seasons, and growers everywhere met it with the same new fungicides (Lucas, Science, 1980). The spores were the same on both sides of every border. The markets, credit and buyers waiting for the leaf were not.

    For us.Before attributing an outcome to a shock, we look for the same shock somewhere else, and ask what was different there.

    A shock as a diagnostic event

    Sally Falk Moore suggested reading certain events as “diagnostic”: moments that expose the contests and arrangements already under way, rather than causes in themselves (American Ethnologist, 1987). Lauren MacLean’s comparison of villages on either side of the Ghana–Côte d’Ivoire border shows how much the state on each side shapes what neighbours with the same language and crops can do (2010).

    For us.When a bad season hits, we record what it reveals about who could absorb it, not only what it destroyed.

    Who pays for the protocol

    Every cure for a crop disease comes with a list of inputs. John Soluri shows how spraying against banana leaf disease in Central America favoured growers who could pay for the equipment, and left its mark on the workers who did the spraying (Banana Cultures, 2005). Pete Daniel traces how tobacco, cotton and rice farming in the American South became capital-intensive, and how many small farmers it left behind (Breaking the Land, 1985).

    For us.When we recommend a practice, we count what it costs a household to follow it: in cash, in labour, and in whose labour.

    Unpaid hands

    Alexander Chayanov argued that family farms survive where wage-paying farms would not, because the household works itself harder than any employer could ask, balancing toil against the mouths it has to feed (The Theory of Peasant Economy, 1925; English 1966). A labour-hungry crop grown by families depends on that arithmetic, and on neighbours who help at harvest.

    For us.A programme that draws one member of a household into wage work changes the sums for everyone who stays, and sometimes for the neighbours too.

    The mistake is the evidence

    Alessandro Portelli found that workers in Terni remembered a comrade’s death at the wrong date, and argued that the error showed what the event meant to them (The Death of Luigi Trastulli, 1991). Luise White read colonial-era rumours that medical campaigns drained people’s blood as histories of how those campaigns were experienced (Speaking with Vampires, 2000). In both, people remember the cure and the harm arriving together.

    For us.When someone tells us a story we know to be wrong in its facts, we ask why it is remembered that way before we correct it.

    African counterpoint

    A peasant without a field

    James Ferguson found Basotho households living mostly on mine wages and still being described as farmers by the development project meant to help them (The Anti-Politics Machine, 1990). The reverse also happens: people who have long since stopped farming go on calling themselves farmers. In the first case the category is imposed; in the second it is kept.

    For us.We ask people what they call themselves before we decide which category they belong in, and we note when the two do not match.

    The question we are keeping. In September we asked whether “peasant” needs agriculture at all. This week turns it around: if a disease ends a crop on one side of a border and not the other, how much of what gets called a natural disaster is a record of who could afford the cure, and who was left to remember it as something done to them?

    Read with: G. B. Lucas, “The War against Blue Mold”, Science (1980); Sally Falk Moore, “Explaining the Present: Theoretical Dilemmas in Processual Ethnography”, American Ethnologist (1987); Lauren M. MacLean, Informal Institutions and Citizenship in Rural Africa (2010); John Soluri, Banana Cultures (2005); Pete Daniel, Breaking the Land (1985); A. V. Chayanov, The Theory of Peasant Economy (1925; English 1966); Alessandro Portelli, The Death of Luigi Trastulli and Other Stories (1991); Luise White, Speaking with Vampires (2000); James Ferguson, The Anti-Politics Machine (1990); Michael Watts, Silent Violence (1983).

  • 6 NovThe Salmon, the Cow, and the Spotted Owl: Endangerment and Federal Power in the American WestMeghan Morris, Temple UniversityOur questionEndangered-species law protects a species wherever it is found; Western water law ranks users by who came first. When the two collide in a drought, which clock wins, the river’s or the deed’s? And who was there before either clock started?
    Colloquium · 6 NovA house the state gaveOur notes

    The session took up a paper in progress, shared with participants in advance, so nothing from it is summarised here. What is kept is our own: the question we asked, about the homesteads around Tule Lake, and where it led when we went back to the public record and to published work on the federal West. Nothing said in the room by others is reported. Our 9 Oct notes already cover the Klamath water rules and the 2001 drought.

    Houses built from a camp

    The Tule Lake War Relocation Center opened in 1942, became a segregation center in 1943 for Japanese Americans the government labelled “disloyal”, and closed in March 1946 (National Park Service). The Bureau of Reclamation then opened the surrounding land to homesteading. Its first post-war drawing on the Tule Lake Division, in 1946, was open only to Second World War veterans and drew 2,150 applicants for 86 farms (Oregon History Project). The Park Service records that the camp’s barracks were turned into houses by homesteaders across the basin.

    For us.Before we take up a community’s grievance against the state, we ask what the state once gave it, and whose loss made the gift possible.

    A betrayal assumes a promise

    Patricia Limerick and Richard White both argue that the federal government made the American West: it conquered and surveyed it, gave out its land, and built the dams and canals that watered it (The Legacy of Conquest, 1987; “It’s Your Misfortune and None of My Own”, 1991). The West’s distrust of Washington grew alongside its dependence on Washington. A complaint of betrayal is evidence of the promise underneath it.

    For us.When people tell us the state betrayed them, we write down what they say was promised, who promised it, and to whom else the same thing was promised.

    Someone has cut the line

    Arlie Hochschild describes the “deep story” she heard in Louisiana: people waiting patiently in line for the American Dream who see others cutting ahead, waved through by the government (Strangers in Their Own Land, 2016). In the Klamath Basin the courts have put the tribes ahead in the line for water. In Baley v. United States (2019) the Federal Circuit held that the 2001 cuts to Project irrigators were not a compensable taking, because senior tribal rights covered at least the water needed for the fish; the Supreme Court declined to hear the case in 2020.

    For us.We ask people where they think they stand in the line, and who they believe put others ahead of them.

    Restored without the land

    The Klamath Termination Act of 1954 ended federal recognition of the Klamath Tribes and dissolved their reservation; most of its forest became the Winema National Forest. Congress restored recognition in 1986 but returned no land (Oregon History Project). The tribes’ place at the front of the line for water sits beside the loss of almost all the land the 1864 treaty had left them.

    For us.When a right is recognised on paper, we ask what came back with it, and what did not.

    Living in the debris

    Ann Laura Stoler asks what empire leaves behind in the places people go on living in: not ruins to visit, but buildings, soils and boundaries that keep doing work long after the order that made them is gone (Imperial Debris, 2013). A barrack turned farmhouse is one such object. Whether anyone in the house still talks about where it came from is part of its history.

    For us.On a first visit we ask how old the buildings are and what they were before, and we notice who answers and who changes the subject.

    African counterpoint

    When the park came first

    Roderick Neumann traces how colonial and then Tanzanian conservation turned the forests of Mount Meru into Arusha National Park, criminalising the Meru’s customary use of the land and imposing a European ideal of untouched wilderness (Imposing Wilderness, 1998). In the Klamath Basin, protecting listed fish runs with the tribes’ senior rights; on Mount Meru, protecting nature was how the first users were pushed out. Which side conservation law falls on depends on whose earlier claim it is willing to recognise.

    For us.When nature is to be protected, we ask whose earlier use the protection ends, and whose earlier claim it honours.

    The question we are keeping. In October we asked who counts as local. This week the question moved inside the house. When a community’s grievance against the state is lived in buildings the state handed out, on land taken from others first, what does a complaint of betrayal tell us about the promise underneath it, and who was never offered that promise?

    Read with: Patricia Nelson Limerick, The Legacy of Conquest (1987); Richard White, “It’s Your Misfortune and None of My Own”: A New History of the American West (1991); Arlie Russell Hochschild, Strangers in Their Own Land (2016); Ann Laura Stoler, ed., Imperial Debris: On Ruins and Ruination (2013); Roderick P. Neumann, Imposing Wilderness (1998); National Park Service, Tule Lake Unit, “Camp Layout”; Oregon History Project, “Tulelake, California” and “Winema National Forest” (2003); Baley v. United States, 942 F.3d 1312 (Fed. Cir. 2019).

  • 13 NovFoothold: Popular Land Control at the Urban Frontier in IndonesiaChristian Lund, University of CopenhagenOur questionHernando de Soto argued that the poor hold “dead capital” for want of a title. At the edge of a growing city, does a paper of any kind protect a household, or only make its plot easier to buy out?Read alongside, from Africa: Catherine Boone, Property and Political Order in Africa (2014).
  • 4 DecCivil Law and Agrarian Capitalism(?) in Late Ottoman Gaza: Old Questions, New SourcesNora Barakat, Stanford UniversityNote to follow.Read alongside, from Africa: Kenneth M. Cuno, The Pasha’s Peasants (1992), on land and law in Ottoman Egypt.
  • 11 DecToo Many Bulls: More-Than-Human Kinship in Borana, EthiopiaYayi Zheng, Visiting Fellow, Program in Agrarian StudiesNote to follow.Read alongside, from Africa: Sharon E. Hutchinson, Nuer Dilemmas (1996), on cattle, money and kinship.

Schedule from the Program’s colloquium page. To attend, subscribe to the Program’s mailing list there.

Before the first visit · 田野前的提问

What the notes add up to: questions we ask before we start.

Every week’s notes end in a line about what it changes for SEESALT. Gathered together, those lines become a field checklist. We read it before a first visit to a village, a school or a farm, and add to it as the term goes on.

Land and water

  1. In a shortage, what rule decides who goes without first?9 Oct
  2. How does water or land actually reach this household: well, pipe, truck, neighbour or patron?9 Oct
  3. If a right exists on paper, who enforces it at the edge, and at what cost to them?18 Sept
  4. What can people fall back on if they say no to us?30 Sept
  5. How long must someone live here before they count as local, and who decides?9 Oct
  6. When a right is recognised on paper, what came back with it, and what did not?6 Nov
  7. When nature is to be protected, whose earlier use does it end, and whose earlier claim does it honour?6 Nov

Counting and categories

  1. Who in the household can write, and who has to ask someone else?25 Sept
  2. What do people call themselves, and does it match our category?30 Oct
  3. What does each indicator assume, and who will argue their way into it or out of it?2 Oct
  4. Who will keep this record true after we leave?2 Oct
  5. What is the least we need to collect, and who must never see it?2 Oct

The state and other authorities

  1. What of the state is already here and not seen as the state? Does it come as the chief?25 Sept
  2. Whose name goes on the road, the clinic, the programme?25 Sept
  3. Which decisions has an emergency taken out of ordinary review, and when do they come back?9 Oct
  4. Where the state is thin, what are we standing in for, and which way does that point?30 Sept
  5. What did the state once give this community, and whose loss made the gift possible?6 Nov
  6. When people say the state betrayed them, what was promised, by whom, and to whom else?6 Nov
  7. Where do people think they stand in the line, and who do they believe put others ahead?6 Nov

Costs, shocks and memory

  1. What does following our advice cost a household, in cash, in labour, and in whose labour?30 Oct
  2. Did the same shock hit somewhere else, and what was different there?30 Oct
  3. Who could absorb the bad season, and who could not?30 Oct
  4. When a story is wrong in its facts, why is it remembered that way?30 Oct
  5. What were these buildings before, and who answers when we ask?6 Nov
  6. What does this programme make possible next, not only what it prevents?25 Sept

Our own position

  1. Which case were our intuitions built on?30 Sept
  2. Which version of this community’s story travels best, and what does it commit them to?18 Sept
  3. When a framework arrives from elsewhere, what does it let people say, and what does it make harder to say?18 Sept
  4. When we ask people to co-invest, who else is being paid, and who is not?30 Sept

Words we keep · 词汇

The vocabulary this term has given us.

Like the word lists in our Kiswahili notes: each term in a line, with where it comes from and the week we met it.

LegibilityJames C. Scott, 1998
A state simplifies what it governs so it can be counted and taxed, and the simplification then remakes the thing counted. Scott
MētisJames C. Scott, 1998
Practical knowledge that lives in experience and resists being written down. Scott
FrictionAnna Tsing, 2005
The sticky local encounters through which universal ideas take hold, and are changed. 18 Sept
ImiduguduKinyarwanda, “villages”
Rwanda’s grouped-settlement policy from the late 1990s. 18 Sept
EjidoMexican land reform
Land granted to a community after the Revolution and worked by ejidatarios who held use rights; the 1992 reform opened it to titling and sale. 25 Sept
Permanent primitive accumulationRoger Bartra
Reform that ties households to plots too poor to live on, so people move between farm and city without arriving. 25 Sept
Decentralised despotismMahmood Mamdani, 1996
Colonial rule of the countryside through “customary” chiefs. 25 Sept
PeasantEric Wolf, 1966
A rural household working for itself while yielding a surplus to others. We asked whether it needs to cultivate at all. 30 Sept
Moral topographyMichael Taussig, via Claudia Leal
Mapping moral qualities onto a landscape and the people who live in it. 30 Sept
Free-womb lawSpanish America, 19th century
Laws freeing children born to enslaved mothers, usually with years of service owed to the mother’s owner. 30 Sept
CampesinadoColombia
The peasantry as a legal and statistical category; since 2023 a constitutional subject of special protection. 2 Oct
CadastreLand administration
A public register of parcels, their boundaries and holders, kept for tax and title. 2 Oct
TutelaColombia
A fast constitutional action anyone can file to protect a fundamental right. 2 Oct
Prior appropriationWestern US water law
First in time, first in right: in a shortage, senior rights are served before junior ones. 9 Oct
AccessRibot and Peluso, 2003
The ability to benefit from a thing, as distinct from the right to it. 9 Oct
AutochthonyPeter Geschiere, 2009
A claim to belong because one’s people were there first, used to sort insiders from strangers. 9 Oct
Diagnostic eventSally Falk Moore, 1987
An event read for what it exposes about arrangements already in play. 30 Oct
Labour–consumption balanceA. V. Chayanov, 1925
A family farm works until the toil of more work outweighs the needs of the mouths it feeds. 30 Oct
TerminationUS federal Indian policy, 1950s–60s
Congress ending federal recognition of a tribe and dissolving its reservation; the Klamath were terminated in 1954 and restored in 1986, without their land. 6 Nov
Deep storyArlie Hochschild, 2016
The story that feels true to people about their place in the world, such as waiting in line while others cut ahead. 6 Nov
Imperial debrisAnn Laura Stoler, 2013
What empire leaves in places people go on living in, still doing work after the order that made it is gone. 6 Nov

An agrarian shelf

Six books we would hand a new consultant before a first rural project.

An addition to our reading list for emerging development practitioners. Each one changed how we ask the first question in a village.

  • James C. Scott, Weapons of the Weak (1985)Read before treating silence as agreement.
  • James C. Scott, Seeing Like a State (1998)Read before designing an indicator.
  • Michael Watts, Silent Violence (1983)Read before calling a famine natural.
  • James Ferguson, The Anti-Politics Machine (1990)Read before writing a project document.
  • Sara Berry, No Condition Is Permanent (1993)Read before assuming who owns the land.
  • Tania Murray Li, The Will to Improve (2007)Read before deciding what the problem is.

Agrarian notes are kept by Zhijun He, SEESALT’s founder, as a student participant in the Program in Agrarian Studies at Yale. SEESALT is an independent volunteer organisation and has no affiliation with Yale University or the Program. Last updated November 2026.