When Young People Are in the Room: UNICEF's New Guidance on Youth in Evaluation

On 20 November, World Children’s Day, the UNICEF Evaluation Office published Engaging Youth Stakeholders and Young Evaluators in UNICEF Evaluations. The guidance was developed with evaluation colleagues across UNICEF’s headquarters, regional and country offices, and with the Evaluation Office’s 2025–2026 Youth Advisory Group, whose recommendations informed both the drafting and the final review. SEESALT’s founder, Zhijun He, served on that group.

We are writing about it here because the guidance speaks to questions SEESALT faces in its own work.

Two ways to be in the room

The guidance draws a distinction that is easy to state and easy to blur in practice. Young people can take part in an evaluation as youth stakeholders, bringing their lived experience as the people a programme is meant to serve. Or they can take part as young and emerging evaluators, bringing professional skills to the evaluation team. The two roles come with different expectations, different support and different responsibilities, and the guidance asks teams to be clear about which one they are offering before they begin.

First, ask whether it adds value

Engagement is not treated as good in itself. The guidance begins with a decision: would involving young people actually improve this evaluation, which role fits, and what form suits the context, whether consultations, a dedicated advisory group or a seat on a wider reference group. It is candid that participation which is vaguely defined or poorly supported can turn symbolic, burdensome or even unsafe.

Closing the loop

One practice we found especially useful is closing the loop: going back to young people afterwards to tell them how their input shaped the evaluation and what happened to its findings. It sounds small, and it is easy to skip. It is also what decides whether someone is willing to take part a second time.

What it means for SEESALT

SEESALT is a volunteer network of young people doing development research, and much of our work involves other young people: students in Sunward’s rural camps, peer facilitators running Guhuza in Rwanda. When our consultants run an evaluation, they are young evaluators; the students they interview are youth stakeholders. Those are different relationships, and the guidance gives us a vocabulary for treating them differently: being explicit about roles, keeping safeguarding in view, and reporting back to the people who gave us their time. The guidance itself covers stakeholders aged 18 to 24. Many of the students we work with are younger, which only raises the bar.

It also leaves us with an honest question. The guidance stresses adequate resources and support for young evaluators. SEESALT pays no one, at any level. What does adequate support look like in a network that runs on volunteer time? We do not have a full answer yet, but we would rather ask it openly than assume goodwill is enough.

The Evaluation Office plans a webinar on the guidance in early 2027. We will share it with our network when it is announced.

Read the guidance: Engaging Youth Stakeholders and Young Evaluators in UNICEF Evaluations

Previous
Previous

The View from Dakar: A Chicken, a Budget and a Word of Wolof

Next
Next

Two Rooms at yale Tsai CITY: Guhuza and Adaptation Lab This Fall